Kelsens two most important books on the pure theory of law are the first edition of his reine rechtslehre, published in 1934 and recently 2002 translated. He published the first edition of the pure theory of law in 1934, and a second, expanded edition which i read in 1960. Clark nphe publication in 196 7 of pure theory of law, a translation ofi the second 1960 german edition of hans kelsens reine rechtslehre, has largely escaped the notice of jurisprudential commentators. Kelsen also wanted to isolate the legal structure and his pure theory of law would describe it would reduce it to anything more than it is.
This paper deals with the basic causes of numerous often extremely negatively intoned critical estimations said on the account of kelsons pure theory of law and exposes essential properties of certain phases of its development. A theory of law is formal, a theory of way of ordering, changing contents the relation of legal theory to a particular system of positive law is that of possible to actual law. The two fudge factors, effectiveness and interpretation, work well to keep kelsens theory grounded in reality, but they also compromise its purity. Pure theory of law law and legal definition uslegal, inc. This book argues that kelsen s legal theory, the pure theory of law, needs to be read in the context. Watch lecture 7 instead in playlist pure theory of law. The essays in part i address legal validity, the normativity of law, and kelsens famous but puzzling idea of a legal systems basic norm. The traditional legal philosophies at the time, were, kelsen claimed, hopelessly contaminated with. Kelsens grand norms is analogous austins concept of sovereign without which law can not be obligatory and binding. Hans kelsens pure theory of law provides a particular approach to law and normativity. This book argues that kelsens legal theory, the pure theory of law, needs to be read in the context. Hans kelson 18811973 introduction credit of reviving the original analytical legal thought in 20th century pure theory of law. Kelsen s theory of grundnorm mridushi swarup this article is an attempt to explain as to what is meant by kelsons theory of grundnorm, in what way are they effective, its functions and whether the concept can be found in the indian constitution. This chapter focuses on whether the kelsenian doctrine of the basic norm can be reconstructed in neokantian terms as the central element in a transcendental theory of legal knowledge.
The present paper purports to provide an analytical reconstruction and critical assessment of such a critique. His major works on legal positivism were the general theory of law and state and the pure theory of law. Immediately he left for heidelberg and proceeded to germany to have first hand. This criticism ignores the limited objective of kelsen which was to present a pure science of law, a formal view of the legal structure. It is this detachment that puts kelsen into the legal positivist school. This paper will begin by outlining kelsens theory and discuss the middleway approach he adopts. May 19, 2016 hans kelsen and puretheory of law hans kelsen advocated pure theory of law. Kelsens theory of grundnorm mridushi swarup this article is an attempt to explain as to what is meant by kelsons theory of grundnorm, in what way are they effective, its functions and whether the concept can be found in the indian constitution. This concluding chapter once again takes up the question of what form of legal theory we find in kelsen. Sheds new light on the relationship between positivist theories of law and political philosophy, by rooting kelsen s pure theory of law in the context of his understanding of political legitimacy. The idea of a pure theory of law was propounded by the formidable austrian jurist and philosopher hans kelsen 18811973 see the bibliographical note. Summary of hans kelsens pure theory of law hugh mccarthy. If you continue browsing the site, you agree to the use of cookies on this website.
This book argues that kelsens pure theory of law needs to be read in the context of kelsens political theory. Hans kelsens pure theory of law legality and legitimacy lars vinx. This criticism ignores the limited objective of kelsen which was to present a. This article will summarize kelsen sopure theory of law, comment on his view of customary court. Pure theory of law confers power to subordinate administrators in order to devise a subordinate legal norm, and to indicate the nature of such norms. The austrian philosopher and jurist named han kelsen proposed the pure theory of law. John austin wrongly titled as the father of english jurisprudence. According to kelsen, the legal system must be pure that is, selfsupporting and not dependent on extralegal values.
Or kelson wishes to free the law from the metaphysical mist which it has been covered of all times. Overview hans kelsen was an austrian legal theorist, who worked in germany until the rise of the nazi party, and then in the usa. He was a professor of law at the vienna university. Kelsens pure theory is about the hierarchy of norms.
Kelsen wanted to isolate what was unique to legal structures. He said that a theory of law must be free from ethics, politics, sociology, history, etc. In a series of essays published from the late 1920s up to the mid1960s, hans kelsen carried out a radical critique of natural law theory. The pure theory of law maintains that laws are norms handed down by the state. This was the lacunae in the command theory as described by austin. Jul 15, 2014 in hindi in hindi in hindi in hindi in hindi in hindi hla hart. This collection of new essays takes kelsens pure theory of law as a stimulus, aiming to move forward the debate on several central issues in contemporary jurisprudence. In 1826 he was appointed to the chair of jurisprudence in the university of london. All about legal theory jurisprudence 70 lessons 15 h 47 m. It is authority supportive that sovereignty must be obeyed and must not be challenged. Neokantian theory of legal knowledge in kelsens pure.
Kelsens juristic definition of delict has been severely criticised. Though their value is not denied, but kelsen insisted that a theory of law must not have such considerations. Slideshare uses cookies to improve functionality and performance, and to provide you with relevant advertising. As kant is followed by hegel, neokantians, including kelsen, are followed by hegelian dialectics. Kelsens book contains only text neither logical notation nor pictures. Hans kelsen and puretheory of law hans kelsen advocated pure theory of law.
Pdf kelsens pure theory of law naveed hussain academia. It offers a grammar and a vocabulary that helps us identify some legal concepts and problems as essential and to dismiss others as alien to the main tasks of legal scholarship. Historical school and analytical school brought together. Lasky commented on kelsens theory of pure law as an exercise in logic and not in life. Introduction by the time he anived in the united states in 1940, hans kelsen was already. On the side of the positivists, the pure theory of law gains more and more ground. Hanno kaiser 2004 1 law and nature law and nature are categorically di. This jurisprudence would focus on nothing other than cognition of the law, that is, on exactly how law is perceived and recognised. The second edition appeared in english translation in 1967, as pure theory of law, the first edition in english translation in 1992, as introduction to the problems of legal theory.
Kelsen, hansdefinition of law 1the legal norm 2the basic norm 3limits of legal analysis 4works by kelsen 5supplementary bibliography 6in the history of modern legal thought, hans kelsen 7 has aroused more responseranging from enthusiastic acceptance to vehement rejection than any. It offers the first comprehensive interpretation of the pure theory that. Jurisprudence pure theory of law by hans kelsen part 2. Jan 01, 2002 pure theory of law ebook written by hans kelsen. This theory is mainly represented by professor hans kelsen, formerly of vienna, now of geneva. For example, kelsen sets up his theory by first making a fundamental distinction between the prescriptive and descriptive aspects of positive law. He released the theory of law entitled the general theory of law and state 1945. Hans kelsen 18811973 one of the most significant european jurists of.
Pure theory of law by kelsen jurisprudence glup4074. Hans kelsen s pure theory of law legality and legitimacy lars vinx. Kelsen was a professor at vienna, cologne, geneva, and the german university in prague. The presentation provide brief introduction to hans kelsens pure theory of law. Chapter six of pure theory of law has kelsen present his celebrated identity theory of law and state. Kelsen began his long career as a legal theorist at the beginning of the 20th century. The idea of a pure theory of law was propounded by the austrian jurist and philosopher hans kelsen.
The second edition, which kelson published in 1960 translated in 1967 is a considerably extended version of the first edition. Conclusionsthe pure theory of law and contemporary positivism. Kelsens pure theory can be said to be one of the most refined developments of analytical positivism. Kelsens pure theory of law introduction generally, law is, a system of rules and regulations which are enforced through social institutions to govern human. Hence, kelsen propounded the idea of a pure theory of law, which is a theory of positive law. The code of the legal system, the formative distinction that creates and perpetuates the identity of the legal system is lawful. Hans kelsen is considered to be one of the founding fathers of modern legal philosophy. Hans kelsens pure theory of law is the most prominent and influential legal theory for continental law systems. Translation from the second german edition by max knight. Key elements of kelsens legal science such as the distinction between subjective and objective legal meaning, the theory of legal order as legal hierarchy, the conception. Download for offline reading, highlight, bookmark or take notes while you read pure theory of law.
Summary of hans kelsens pure theory of law hugh mccarthys. Rather, his aim was to present law as it is, free from all the various ideologies. Pdf visualization of hans kelsens pure theory of law. Hans kelsen, austrianamerican legal philosopher, teacher, jurist, and writer on international law, who formulated a kind of positivism known as the pure theory of law. Kelsens normative relativism presupposition is a matter of choice relative to the point of view relative to actual conduct, beliefs and attitudes. It is a general theory of law, not an interpretation of specific national or international legal norms. Impurities in kelsens pure theory hugh mccarthys asc blog. Kelsens pure theory kelsens theory seeks to isolate that which makes law valid without reference to morality. This chapter discusses kelsens claim that the pure theory of law is a purely descriptive science of law. Kelsens theory claims be precise and concrete, and to separate law from other concerns such as morality and sociology. Here is harts criticism, which argues that kelsens definition fails crucially to distinguish between a fine and a tax. It was a pure theory because it would describe law without reducing it to. There kelsens pure theory of law is a theory of positive law based on normative order criminating all extra legal and nonlegal elements from it. It is characterized as a pure theory of law because it aims to focus on law alone.
Hans kelsens pure theory of law 253 kelsens goal in developing the pure theory was to make possible a valuefree jurisprudence or a science of law. It was a pure theory because it would describe law without reducing it to psychology, sociology or the like. In the new pure theory of law, validity of the norm is much more closely linked. This kelsenian selfunderstanding turns out to be questionable. Part one surveys the fundamentals of kelsens argumentative strategy against natural law and its theorists. Hans kelsen was an austrian legal theorist, who worked in germany until the rise of the nazi party, and then in the usa.
Henry cohen hans kelsen 18811973 was a leading germanamerican legal positivist. Reine rechtslehre is a book by legal theorist hans kelsen, first published in 1934 and in a greatly expanded second edition effectively a new book in 1960. Though the first exposition of theory took place in 1911, it came in full bloom in. Kelsons pure theory of law according to kelson a theory of law should be uniform.
Dec 09, 2014 kelsens desire for rigour and precision is risky because the theory might begin to deviate from a reasonable understanding of law. With his pure theory of law, hans kelsen did not wish to present any new ideology of law. This is kelsen s highly functional theory of the state and the law as representing the same entity. It offers the first comprehensive interpretation of the pure theory that makes systematic use. This distinguished kelsens views from the scandinavian realists.
And, on the basis of this criticism, more extensive criticism of the pure theory become apparent. He published the first edition of the pure theory of law in 1934, and a second, expanded edition which i read in 1960 the theory is pure because it separates jurisprudence from other disciplines like ethics, politics and psychology. Updated lecture on kelsens pure theory of law lecture 4 in the jurisprudence lecture series for ll. From an intrasystemic, internal, or legal point of view, law is norm, not fact. This book argues that kelsens legal theory, the pure theory of law, needs to be read in the context of kelsens political theory. It is not to be confused with the sociological domain or the cultural domain of intersubjective activity. The pure theory of law is devised for traceability of each legal act to be in line with the penned constitution. Born in 1790 early age entered in army served for 5 years. Kelson pure theory of law is based on pyramid structure of hierarchy of norms which drive there validity from the basic norm which he termed as. It argues that the pure theory is best understood as an attempt to find a middle ground between natural law and legal positivism that may serve to reconnect positivist legal thought in a distinctive and so far unexplored way with normative political theory.
But despite kelsen s prominence as a legal theorist, his political theory has been mostly overlooked. He insisted that a theory of law must be free from ethics, politics, sociology, history, etc. In describing it as a science of norms kelsen wanted a description of the structure of law that was free of evaluative terms. The jurisprudence kelsen propounded characterizes itself as a pure theory of law because it aims at cognition focused on the law alone and. Continuation the unbridgeable gap between the ought and the is he sees the difference between factual world and normative world. Part two considers, in turn, two critical reactions to kelsens criticisms. As a theory it is exclusively concerned with the accurate definition of its subject matter.
Sheds new light on the relationship between positivist theories of law and political philosophy, by rooting kelsens pure theory of law in the context of his understanding of political legitimacy. Hans kelsen s pure theory of law in the land of the legal realists d. Essays in hans kelsens pure theory and related problems in international law, by george arthur lipsky 1953. But despite kelsens prominence as a legal theorist, his political theory has been mostly overlooked. Jan 29, 20 according to austin, law is command of sovereign backed by sanction. Kelsen justified his grundnorm theory by explaining that there has to be a source for the creation of valid laws. The first question then is whether the problematic that underlies kelsens doctrine of the basic norm can be regarded, structurally speaking, as epistemological in the neokantian sense at all. Further a critical analysis has been drawn to come to a viable opinion with regard to the theory. Kelson did not favour widening the scope of jurisprudence by corelating it with all social sciences and rigorously. I think that there are at least two fudge factors that are imprecise, and allow these other disciplines to bleed back into the theory. Apr 07, 2015 kelsens grand norms is analogous austins concept of sovereign without which law can not be obligatory and binding.
Professor voegellnis comment onth s conti bution to the austrian constitution is that it is the most important event in themoderl1 history of constitutions from the point of view of legal technique, and adds that with its. Pure theory of law tension between normative relativism and antireductionism. Reine rechtslehre is a book by legal theorist hans kelsen, first published in. This book argues that kelsen s legal theory, the pure theory of law, needs to be read in the context of kelsen s political theory. Hans kelsen and his pure theory of law berkeley law. It should be applicable to all times and in all places. A comparison of hobbes, bentham and kelsen avebury series in philosophy sep 1990. The pure theory of law which is also known as vienna school of legal thought was propounded by hans kelson, a professor in vienna austria university. What are the mains points of criticism of this theory. The implications of kelsens theory are wide and many. Among legal philosophers, the timehonored dispute between naturallaw schools and legal positivists arouses ever new interest. The pure theory of law stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. Kelsen, an analytical jurist, in his pure theory of law says, law is the norm which stipulates sanction.
1091 859 608 1392 990 699 1151 914 647 1209 1311 1324 1518 1190 1202 678 259 255 720 776 1407 1493 203 148 792 1309 686 501 717 569 479 1290